| 
View
 

Heather Bullock

Page history last edited by heather Bullock 15 years, 2 months ago

 

 

I chose to do my research on children who were adopted and how teachers can better serve them.  This is a subject very dear to my heart, as I adopted three beautiful, African-American children.  It has been my privilege, and my responsibility, to raise my children and guide them through the experiences of an inter-racial family and all the good and bad that comes with that.  I feel that not only am I a teacher to my children, but I also have a responsibility to educate the general population on positive adoption language.  I have spent years researching the topic of adoption from a parental perspective, so it was my desire to research this topic from an educator’s perspective.

According to the American Academy of Child &Adolescent Psychiatry, approximately 120,000 children are adopted each year in the United States (2006).  There are several different kinds of adoption: international, private infant, foster-adoption, and open infant adoption are the most common.  Children who have been adopted have unique challenges in their education and in their family life.  Some adopted children may develop emotional or behavioral problems. The problems may or may not result from insecurities or issues related to being adopted (AACAP). 

 

There is evidence of children who have been adopted having a higher incidence of ADD/ADHD and learning disabilities.  Investigators found that the most common clinical symptoms manifested by adopted children were externalizing in nature—namely, attention deficit hyperactivity disorder; oppositional, defiant, and conduct problems; and substance abuse. In addition, higher rates of learning problems were noted in this group of children (Palacios, 2010).

 

Adolescent children who have been adopted can struggle with their identity to a greater degree than adolescent children who live with their biological parents.  There is often a lack of information about their biological parents and, in cases of international adoption, this lack of information is highlighted.  Much has been written about this area. Adoptees often report feeling different from their peers, and having those differences reflected in the comments and actions of others (Brodzinsky et al, 1992).

What does this mean for educators?  The days of the traditional nuclear family are long gone. You can no longer rely on lesson plans based on mom-dad-and-two-kids. You need to allow for non-traditional families.  In fact, any class assignment which ignores the variety in families today does real harm to students who don't fit the traditional pattern and as a result feel out of place, even excluded, in class discussions (Hilborn, 2005).

Additionally, parents may be reluctant to share information about their children’s adoption with teachers.  Many parents are concerned about their children being labeled or singled out in some way, and they often worry that school staff will not take their concerns seriously (Dominguez, L, 2010).

What can teachers do to service adopted children and their families?  Here are some practical options for teachers:

 

  • Be sensitive to the families and let them take the lead in how much information they share about their situation. 

 

 

  • Change traditional lessons that exclude adopted students to be more inclusive.  For example, having students bring in a picture of themselves as a baby may be impossible for adopted children, especially foster-adopted children.  Instead, reach the same educational goal, for everyone in the class, by broadening the assignment. To illustrate growth and change, bring a picture when the child was younger or smaller, or follow the growth of a baby chick after hatching. To describe a child, bring in something else which tells us more about her -- a book, a trophy, a pet. To test reasoning ability (guess who this is?), bring a picture of someone we all know; or, describe someone with three clues, adding one at a time until someone guesses correctly (Hilborn).

 

  • Do your research.  Read the latest adoption research and strategies.  Constantly educate yourself. 

 

  • Recognize that students who have been adopted might not always be able to handle questions from their peers about adoption.  When this happens, re-direct the conversation.

 

  • Promote a safe learning community in which every student is respected and every voice is heard. 

 

The goal is to lead by example and to be constantly working for a classroom in which no student is singled out.  As an adoptive parent, I have most appreciated the teachers who have partnered with me to create a learning environment in which my children were empowered to choose whether or not to share information about their adoption with their peers.  I meet with my children’s teachers every year to discuss my children’s adoption status and the learning challenges my children face.  As a teacher, I recognize that not every parent is as open as I am about the adoption.  It is important that I respect that and be a partner with each student and family that enters my classroom.

 

Guest Speaker

 

Meet Caitlyn.  Caitlyn is in highschool and she and her siblings were adopted by their paternal grandparents when Caitlyn was a toddler.  She now lives with her grandparents and younger brother.  Caitlyn is bi-racial and is a lovely young woman who has adjusted well to her unique family situation.

 

References

 

American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry. (2006). The adopted child. Facts for Families, No. 15.

 

Brodzinsky, D, et al.  Being adopted: The lifelong search for self. New York: Doubleday.

 

Dominguez, L. Tools & Strategies for Promoting School Success. The Center for Adoption Support & Education, Inc.  Retrieved from: http://www.adoptionsupport.org/newsletter/2010/FAll_2010.pdf

 

Hilborn, R. (2005). Teacher’s guide to adoption (2nd ed.). Family Helper. Retrieved from http://www.familyhelper.net/ad/adteach.html

 

Palacios, J and Broadzinsky, D. (2010).  Review: Adoption research: Trends, topics, outcomes. International Journal of Behavioral Development.  34:270. Retrieved from: http://jbd.sagepub.com/content/34/3/270.

 

Return to Summer 2011

Comments (31)

tomgilgenbach@gmail.com said

at 8:16 pm on Jul 12, 2011

It's so great you have such in depth knowledge of adoption and are becoming a teacher. You'll have an ideal background for giving adopted kids the compassion they need.

heather Bullock said

at 8:21 pm on Jul 12, 2011

Thanks! My experiences as a parent of adopted children is one of the main reasons I chose to go into education. Those are my kids in the above picture, by the way. Just to brag! ;)

kristina.noel@... said

at 6:19 pm on Jul 22, 2011

Cute Family!

Melissa said

at 12:33 am on Jul 13, 2011

Heather, as a fellow adoptive parent, your topic is very important to me! I love your ideas, especially about positive adoption language. What an awesome family photo, thank you for sharing your story. You will be a great advocate for all of us!

Matthew Arnold said

at 5:30 pm on Jul 13, 2011

I am adopted myself (I am white and my parents are white.) I'm still surprised by the reactions I get when I "come out" as an adopted person. Some people respond really surprised ("But you're so normal!"), others assume I have some deep seated issues about it ("It must be so hard to know your mom abandoned you."), and others are just ignorant ("Oh, you don't have a mom and dad?"). It inevitably comes up with every class I teach and elementary kids are SO honest about what they think! I explain that I was adopted at two weeks and that my mom and dad are my adoptive mom and dad that I've known all my life.

Your research - especially the positive adoption language - is really key! Thanks for sharing!

Sheena Cook-Fuglsang said

at 12:00 pm on Jul 14, 2011

I am interested on all of your thoughts. We have a very mixed family (on one side, with my dad and step mom). I have two step sisters who have been in my life for almost 20 years as well as two blood sisters. When I was 16, we brought in a foster child, who we adopted two years later. It is difficult for me to treat everyone exactly the same. I feel like we all have unique relationships, and I don't like to pretend that they are all the same. As a result, my sister (the one who was adopted), has often expressed feeling of being left out. It doesn't help that she lives several states away, which is further than anyone else in the family. Also, to make matters more complicated, she is a lesbian and most of my family (outside of my 2 blood sisters) have problems with. Anyway, how do I help her to feel better, without manufacturing feelings and pretending our relationship is something it is not?

Natalie Linden said

at 8:00 pm on Jul 14, 2011

The advice of letting parents of adopted children take the lead on sharing information is really helpful and important to keep in mind. The pity card is something you touch on and Matthew also discussed. Adoption shouldn't be connected with loss and sadness, and teachers, of all people, who are modeling for students need to be careful of how they interact with students who are adopted.

Jon Nelson said

at 2:13 pm on Jul 15, 2011

Heather, I have two cousins who are adopted. Just recently my cousin Meg met her birth mother and learned about her biological father. I agree with you that lessons can not be planned to the traditional mom-dad families because of the vast diversity in relationships. It is great that you work with the teacher and it must feel very comforting if the teacher is willing to work with you and your children when it comes to adoption. Children have enough pressures - adoption I would believe would add to the pressure.

karie.hickman@... said

at 9:28 pm on Jul 15, 2011

I really like your statements about continuing to educate ourselves as teachers about adoption and the latest research. It is important for us as educators to be sensitive to their privacy and their timing about sharing information about their families and their backgrounds. You are an amzing role model for all parents and educators. Do you work with others looking to adopt and share their lives?

corissa.hanna@... said

at 7:06 pm on Jul 18, 2011

It is important as teachers to stay up to date and continue to learn strategies in the classroom to help students learn in a positive, non-judgemental atmosphere. I bought my wedding dress yesturday and the funds will go to a family who are trying to adopt a child soon. I did not realize the cost associated with adoption.

John Bowman said

at 11:37 am on Jul 19, 2011

Heather, this is a subject that also is close to me, as well. I was born in St. Paul but adopted through Children's Home Society of Minnesota, by a married couple from the Iron Range in their 40's, in 1969. Being transplanted into a region rich with traditionalism and ethnic pride (Scandinanvian), and being a person without any Scandinavian traits, I was reminded of that a lot in the area, because, for some reason, traditional culture was important there. It mattered if you were different in any way. This was a Lutheran-Scandinavian region, with a lot of closed doors. As one who was adopted, I always felt out of place, here.

heather Bullock said

at 3:15 pm on Jul 19, 2011

Sheena, the best thing you can do is listen to your sister. Just having someone who will listen is great. You could also do little things to include her. Call her a bit more, send pictures of your family, etc. You don't have to fake it to improve your relationship. Show her you accept her for who she is.

heather Bullock said

at 3:20 pm on Jul 19, 2011

kari, I have helped friends who have expressed an interest in adoption by answering their questions and pointing them in the right direction. I have a friend in Alaska who wanted to foster-adopt, but was scared. She and her husband had a miscarriage and wanted to start a family. They sat down with me and my ex and we had a very real conversation about foster-adoption, the joys and challenges of adopting in thsi way. They fostered a baby boy whom they were allowed to adopt a year later. Four months after they brought their boy home, she found out she was pregnant and had a baby girl. They fostered another baby boy, whom they adopted, and just had a second biological baby boy. I love being able to help answer questions about adoption and be a support for people considering it. I wish more people would foster-adopt, and wish i could too, because there are so many children in the US free for adoption - meaning their biological parents' rights have been terminated. They are waiting for people to adopt them.

heather Bullock said

at 3:25 pm on Jul 19, 2011

John, identity issues are huge with adoption. Children can feel out of place. I think it is so important for parents to not take offense to their children wanting to look for their biological parents, and it is important for these children to feel included. My kids are African-American and we celebrate Kwanzaa every year and Black History Month. I try to show them role positive role models who are African-American. They were incredibly proud when Obama was elected president, it was a huge historical milestone for them. My sons are very much into hockey, and we often look up African-American hockey players and follow their accomplishments. I have included my children in Icelandic culture, as I am Icelandic, and I tell them it is their culture too. I also have a picture of their biological mother on our "family wall" and a file on each of their biological parents for when they ask about them. I will fully support their search for their biological parents if they choose it.

kristina.noel@... said

at 6:20 pm on Jul 22, 2011

Thanks for posting the information on what teachers can do to support students who are adopted. I think that will really come in handy as we are seeing this more and more. I have two students at my daycare who were adopted.. a boy and girl both from Russia but from different families. Its interesting to watch the boy and girl interact like they have grown up together and are blood related. So cool

carrie.jansen@live.bemidjistate.edu said

at 11:10 pm on Jul 22, 2011

I have to ask even though it is off topic. Is that picture taken on the break wall in front of the Grand Marais Harbor lighthouse? I grew up near Grand Marais, attended k-12 there and that is where I am hoping to teach! By the way great topic.

tomgilgenbach@gmail.com said

at 8:51 am on Jul 23, 2011

Heather, what do you think of the adoption process in general? My wife and I attempted adoption back in the early 90s but it was so expensive we had to give up. We were very lucky when she got pregnant, but had she not, we would have somehow found a way to adopt. We just felt like we were being sucked dry for no reason. I hope it's changed since then.

Sarah W-Prill said

at 11:34 am on Jul 23, 2011

When I am talking to a class about getting permission from their parents for something, I usually refer to their 'families,' instead of parents because I have a few students who are being raised by their grandparents or aunts or uncles. Is this correct? I have always wondered. 'Guardian' sounds too sterile to me, but I really don't want to offend or hurt anyone. What term would you use when addressing a group of students in this way? (Great research, btw!)

Liza Wishard said

at 3:17 pm on Jul 23, 2011

Great question Sarah. When I was composing my summary on diabetes, I was trying to figure out the same thing: how to reference the parents, families, or like of the students. I settled on "care givers", but still not sure if that is adequate. Heather or Caitlyn, would love to get your insight.

Melissa said

at 4:55 pm on Jul 23, 2011

How about "whoever usually gives you permission"? (or something like that). For some of my foster children I am not able to sign permission slips for certain things. I am their caregiver, the county is their guardian, but the parent still has the right to sign. Another thing that bothers my nephew, is when people say "parents" plural. It is just him and his mother (his father passed away). It is just a reminder that he doesn't have two parents. Granted he is more sensitive about it than other people, but I always think about him when I am saying parents, family, etc...

Eugene Floersch III said

at 1:34 pm on Jul 23, 2011

My wife and I have always had great respect for people who adopt. It is a great act of unselfishness. At our church we have a couple that have 6 biological kids and 6 black adopted kids. My 2 kids had the priviledge of going to Sunday with them. I remember my son at a young age not even realizing that they were different. Do you get strange looks when in public from others when they see your family?

heather Bullock said

at 9:21 pm on Jul 23, 2011

Carrie, no that picture is up at the Two Harbors Lighthouse. We went up to walk along the north Shore and see the fall colors.
Tom, Our adoption was free. I think we paid less than $1,000.00 up front, but we were reimbursed for those expenses at the finalization of the adoption. The children get Medicaid free until they each turn 18 and they get a monthly adoption subsidy until they are 18. The subsidy for the three of them is around $2500.00 a month. Adoption can be done inexpensively; it depends on what type of adoption you want to do. It can be a long process or a short one. Ours took nearly two years to finalize, but I have friends who adopted in six months.
Sarah, I think using the word family is perfectly fine, or caregivers would be fine too. Eugene, sometimes we get strange looks, but most of the time, people are just curious, not malicious. It still seems strange, I think, for people to see a multiracial family. Most people though just come up and say something kind.

benjamin.hauser@... said

at 10:03 am on Jul 24, 2011

To what do you contribute the higher rates of ADD, AD/HD, and learning disabilities? I work at a school for students with EBD and we have a lot of adopted/foster children. I am always curious about these kinds of correlations.

emily.lashornewalz@... said

at 10:30 am on Jul 24, 2011

I was very interested in the adoption-sensitive language, thank you for posting that link! I think this language also applies to our kids who are being raised by family members, in foster care, etc, which are so many of our students.

Jon Nelson said

at 11:26 am on Jul 24, 2011

Hi Caitlyn, Thanks for sharing your story. I am curious if you have ever met your biological mother or father? I ask this because I have two cousins who are adopted and one of them has made contact with her bio-mom. My aunt and cousin went and had a very pleasant meeting with Meg's bio-mom. I also have a cousin -in-law if that makes any sense, that just met his bio-mother as well, he also had a wonderful experience. Thanks.

Jeanne Sause said

at 11:53 pm on Jul 24, 2011

Adopted kids are one thing, but I think you are right, another element is brought to the table if the parent(s) and the kids are not of the same ethnicity or color. I don't think other kids would really notice if someone was adopted, at least in the younger grades, if they were the same color and/or ethnicity as their parents. However, a good friend of mine in high school (white) had a brother who was very much brown. Both parents were very white. For years kids would talk about how the brother MUST be adopted. But to this day, and I was very very close to this family, they deny that he was adopted. I don't get it. Is that biologically possible? I mean, you can say he is and always has been part of their family, they have always been his parents, she, always his sister, etc. But why would someone who seems to clearly have adopted their child seem so unwilling to admit it? Is thee shame in it? OR, maybe he was truly NOT adopted? I have come to believe that he was not, even though I don't understand it at all. Oddly enough, his dad was our school counselor, so everyone know how much he did not look like him. As a teacher, how would you handle the situation if you heard kids talking about it?

Jeanne Sause said

at 11:54 pm on Jul 24, 2011

I also wonder how many kids who have been adopted (particularly at a very young age, or birth) KNOW that they are adopted? How does a parent decide when to tell them? I can't imagine what it would be like, and I would guess it is different based on the personality of every child and/or parent.

heather Bullock said

at 7:14 am on Jul 28, 2011

Caity never got the e-mail to log in, she told me to tell you all that she is very sorry she couldn't respond. I asked her your question, Jon, and she gave me this reply: I know my parents. My mom and dad both live nearby and I see my mom about once every few months. my dad comes to visit. It's his parents that adopted me and my brother and sister. My sister doesn't live with us.

heather Bullock said

at 7:20 am on Jul 28, 2011

Jeanne, every family is different in how much information they share with their children and with other people. it used to be such a stigma to be adopted and there was some shame in it, I think. now, as it has become more common, I think people are more comfortable sharing adoption info. As a teacher, I would explain that families are made up in many different ways and that it is not anyone's place to judge how someone's family is made up. i would also do a lesson plan on family differences and a lesson on gossiping.

In regards to what children know, I can only speak for our family. We told our children from day one. We chose to celebrate it. It would be pretty hard to hide as they are very brown and we are very white. LOL. We celebrate "kinfolk day" which is our version of a "gotcha day." The kids picked out the name. It is the day we finalized our adoption, March 4th, and the kids get presents every year and get to pick out what special activity we do on that day. It is like a second birthday for the kids.

Kristina Olson said

at 8:04 pm on Jul 28, 2011

I often wonder about modifying lesson for children who are adopted. Your tips are great, as sometimes I assume that everyone lives with their biological parents. However, that's what this class was about and your information was another awesome insight to a marginalized population that isn't always on a radar.

Kristina Olson said

at 1:03 pm on Aug 1, 2011

PEER REVIEW for Heather Bullock!!

Heather – you have great references. I can tell you put a lot of effort into researching. You also have two hard copy resources. 25/25 points.

Adoption is such a hard topic because typically, like yourself, you LOVE and TREAT your kids the same as if they were biologically yours. As a teacher I imagine that you might forget that someone is adopted when doing say a history project on family heritage. That could be tough for someone who is adopted. A teacher must consider other ways of approaching this for an adopted child. You have great tips for teachers! 25/25 points.

Your wiki page looks great, as well as your summary and references. You answered several questions of our peers and your authentic experience with adoption helped a lot! Thanks for sharing. However, you didn’t comment on EVERYone’s pages but a lot of them you did. 22/25 points

You have a nice little introductory to Caitlyn (AV), but unfortunately she wasn’t able to comment on questions due to technical difficulties. YOU did a great job filling in for her, which was helpful! 20/25 points

You don't have permission to comment on this page.