| 
  • If you are citizen of an European Union member nation, you may not use this service unless you are at least 16 years old.

  • You already know Dokkio is an AI-powered assistant to organize & manage your digital files & messages. Very soon, Dokkio will support Outlook as well as One Drive. Check it out today!

View
 

O'Neil, Anna

Page history last edited by Anna O'Neil 13 years ago

Steffanie Bristow Steffanie Bristow Miller, Marissa Miller, Marissa Miller, Marissa The topic for this page is Buddhism.  This page will include discussion from Thanawat Sriwot aka Steven O'Neil.  Steven is 18 years old and a former Buddhist monk from Wang Pa Pao,-near Chiang Rai Thailand.  He spent 4 years there in a Buddhist run school and left the monastery in June, 2009 and moved to the U.S.  He currently resides in Aurora, MN where he attends Mesabi East High School.  

 

Independent research

 

 I undertook research of Buddhism. Buddhism originated with a man named Siddhartha Gautama about 2,500 years ago, who sought to better understand the nature of the world. Currently, there are 376,000,000 followers world wide. There are various schools and sub-groupings of Buddhism however all Buddhist share some fundamental beliefs. ("Buddhism: an introduction," )

First, in Buddhism, there is no belief in a personal God, nor is the religion based on any relationship between humans and a God. Followers instead look to Buddhism to focus on how individuals develop spiritually in order to carefully and deeply understand the true nature of life.

One of the fundamental concepts that Buddhists aim to seek is that everything in life is interconnected. Buddhists closely examine causes and effects, and recognize that everything changes and is impermanent. Because of this special connectedness, Buddhist consider compassion as a paramount virtue and goal. This concept underlies Buddha's (Siddhartha Gautama) teachings. The teachings begin with “The Four Noble Truths” which are:

  1. The truth of suffering

  2. The truth of the cause suffering

  3. The truth of the end of suffering

  4. The truth of the path to end suffering

These truths can be described as 1 and 2, which diagnose the problem- suffering. Truths 3 and 4 describe how to solve the problem of suffering.

According to Buddha suffering can be part of being elderly, ill or dying. Suffering also exists because people are never really satisfied. The have many desires and expectations and are always in want for more. Eventually, what we have becomes monotonous. To Buddha, suffering is caused specifically by:

  1. Greed and desire

  2. Ignorance and delusion

  3. Hatred and destructive urges ("Religions, buddhism")

Buddha also taught that the way to release yourself from the causes of suffering, like desire, was to give up attachment. The Buddhist aims to know things clearly, without becoming enchanted with them. A key to this understanding is the idea that everything is changing and nothing is permanent. Once a person is able to extinguish the causes of suffering (greed, delusion and hatred, as above) they reach Nirvana- or enlightenment. This can be thought of as obtaining a state of mind marked by joy, without negative emotions or fear. In Buddhist tradition, an enlightened person is filled with compassion for all living things.

Lastly, Buddhists believe that the way to obtain Nirvana is by subscribing to particular rules of living. This is known as the eight-fold path or “The Middle Way.” The conscripts promote moderation as follows, according the the BBC's “Religions” website.

       1.  Right Understanding

    • Accepting Buddhist teachings. (The Buddha never intended his followers to believe his teachings blindly, but to practice them and judge for themselves whether they were true.)

  1. Right Intention - Sammā san̄kappa

    • A commitment to cultivate the right attitudes.

  2. Right Speech - Sammā vācā

    • Speaking truthfully, avoiding slander, gossip and abusive speech.

  3. Right Action - Sammā kammanta

    • Behaving peacefully and harmoniously; refraining from stealing, killing and overindulgence in sensual pleasure.

  4. Right Livelihood - Sammā ājīva

    • Avoiding making a living in ways that cause harm, such as exploiting people or killing animals, or trading in intoxicants or weapons.

  5. Right Effort - Sammā vāyāma

    • Cultivating positive states of mind; freeing oneself from evil and unwholesome states and preventing them arising in future.

  6. Right Mindfulness - Sammā sati

    • Developing awareness of the body, sensations, feelings and states of mind.

  7. Right Concentration - Sammā samādhi

    • Developing the mental focus necessary for this awareness. ("Religions, buddhism," )

 

A great resource teaching the fundamentals of major world religions

http://www.bbc.co.uk/religion/religions/

 

Buddhism and education

 

According to Sanders, children raised by Buddhist parents have higher attainment of education beyond high school than the majority in the United States. This may be because of a greater interest in education as promoted by the religion, or perhaps from a personal investment standpoint. Regardless, this cultural group is becoming increasingly present in the U.S. education system and it is important to consider how this may have a bearing on best practices. (Sander, 2009)

 

In addition, the state of Minnesota requires that all students be taught about major world religions, Buddhism included. This spirituality offers a perspective that may seem very different than what most students are familiar with. This being case, it is important as a teacher to find a way students can learn from each other by finding a system of dialogue that makes sense to everyone. ("Minnesota academic standards," 2005)

 

While conducting my research, I came upon a fascinating article on “Interfaith Dialogue.” This is defined by  Massoudi, as learning from the “other.” According to the author, dialogue is different from what often occurs today both in schools and life where people communicate in monologue or lecture, and attempt to change another person's view, or, simply exchange facts or information. Inspired by Buddhism, the article suggests that people are interconnected as individuals within a boundless system and that dialogue, or learning, is constantly occurring amongst ourselves whether we are aware of it or not. (Massoudi, 2006)

 

Massoudi prescribes ways to engage in interfaith dialogue that would be effective in a classroom setting. The elements are described as follows.

 

1st. Before dialogue

When engaging in dialogue (especially about religion) people exchange both emotion and reason. Respect and tolerance for others views must be displayed. More over, “There must be a genuine belief that the other person's point of view is as valid and as appropriate as one's own view or path.” (Massoudi, 2006)

 

2nd, During dialogue

The author states that most importantly, people should attempt to have an open mind or, “beginner's mind,” that is essentially blank from judgment and open to new possibilities. Also, approach dialogue with a sense of curiosity and wonder. To do this, a person shouldn't try to label, classify or simplify what another person is relaying.

According to Massoudi, Buddhism dictates that one must act with “equanimity accompanied by generosity and patience which allows and gives the other person the opportunity to present his views without feeling intimidated, threatened or criticized.” This can be done by not acting angry when being criticized. Also one must not act pleased or happy when praised. Its important to be mindful of our thoughts and words in order to aid in the conduct and peaceful atmosphere of the dialogue. (Massoudi, 2006)

 

3rd, After the dialogue

This begins with contemplation to review what was learned and what happened in the first two stages of the dialogue. Tibetan Buddhism refers to this as “meditating on exchanging yourself with others.” (Massoudi, pg 431). Its an opportunity to try and understand from the other persons point of view and perhaps even try and put yourself in their shoes. It is also a time to think about how the dialogue may have changed or transformed you.(Massoudi, 2006)

 

Massoudi's description of interfaith dialogue seems to provide for rich meaningful learning opportunities that also build compassion and community. They can be applied to religion, but to other topics as well. They seem appropriate in the classroom. Many activities I have learned about regarding differentiation, communication, motivation, community building and multiculturalism seem to be parallel to this article. I hope to help my students develop skills and a classroom environment that foster these skills towards effective dialogue.

 

Buddhism: an introduction. (n.d.). Retrieved from http://www.pbs.org/edens/thailand/buddhism.htm

 

Life of the buddha. (n.d.). Retrieved from http://www.thebuddhistsociety.org/resources/index.html

 

Massoudi, M. (2006). A system theory approach to interfaith dialogue. Intercultural Education17(4), Retrieved from http://web.ebscohost.com.bsuproxy.mnpals.net/ehost/pdfviewer/pdfviewer?sid=4446f5f1-b442-404f-a421-69fc5e29a17b%40sessionmgr114&vid=2&hid=112

 

Minnesota academic standards - social studies 2004. (2005, August 26). Retrieved from http://education.state.mn.us/MDE/Academic_Excellence/Academic_Standards/Social_Studies/index.html

 

Religions, buddhism. (n.d.). Retrieved from http://www.bbc.co.uk/religion/religions/buddhism/

 

Sander, William. (2009). Religious background and educational attainment: the effects of buddhism, islam, and judaism. Economics of Education Review,29(3), Retrieved from http://www.sciencedirect.com.bsuproxy.mnpals.net/science?_ob=ArticleURL&_udi=B6VB9-4X315K3-1&_user=1822386&_coverDate=06%2F30%2F2010&_rdoc=1&_fmt=high&_orig=gateway&_origin=gateway&_sort=d&_docanchor=&view=c&_acct=C000054885&_version=1&_urlVersion=0&_userid=1822386&md5=9a2eebe181f263d418b7876a655f0a3a&searchtype=a

 

Comments (28)

Brenda Mattei said

at 10:49 am on Apr 7, 2011

How did Aurora become his U.S. destination place to live? There maybe some relations there I see, but even so, what were the struggles/issues he found with moving to Aurora?

Anna O'Neil said

at 1:32 pm on Apr 8, 2011

My Uncle from MN moved to Thailand many years ago. He served in Vietnam and was sort of drawn back to the region after having struggles integrating back into American life after the war. We all sort of lost track of him for years. However he ended up settling in Thailand were he met a Thai woman and had two children. My uncle died when the kids were young (3 an 7 years old). After his death, it was difficult for the mother to care for the children. Years later after family in the US became aware of Steven and his Sister, (and after overcoming several obstacles,ie communication barriers, DNA test, citizenship issues, and much other drama) My dad offered to have Steven and his sister teenagers come live with him in Aurora, MN USA. They took my dad up on his offer. In July 2009 My dad and I went to Thailand and came back with Steven then 17 an Rebecca then 13! My wonderful cousins who I am so thankful to have in my life now! There have been issues! and adapting has been difficult. I will elaborate more on these struggles in a bit

Jaime Goulet said

at 2:23 pm on Apr 7, 2011

I agree Brenda...being from Virginia, I was shocked to see that he is currently in Aurora. How did his family or he decide on that place? Why doesn't he want to reside in a Buddhist rich environment? I mean, I really don't see a problem with living in Aurora, but he doesn't have anything to relate to in regards to Buddhism, unless Aurora has recently seen an increase in Buddhist activities and practices???

David L Zuck said

at 10:05 pm on Apr 7, 2011

We had some sort of Buddhist household on the street I lived on in Ashton, MD and my wife lived near lake Calhoun across the street from such a house as well. So I guess I'm confused by your question especially given the practice too? If we recognize a strong interconnectedness then can't we live anywhere? What am I missing? I love that Interfaith Dialogue, could maybe serve as a metaphor for a newly emphasized approach in the US.

Anna O'Neil said

at 1:52 pm on Apr 8, 2011

Buddhism can be practiced anywhere, anytime, and anyplace. I'll go out on a limb and say that Buddhism is really a way of life...At least I think that is a better way to describe it as opposed to religion. I'm interested in your metaphor reference. Is there a "newly emphasized approach" in particular that your referring too? Or are you offering a prescription?

David L Zuck said

at 7:55 pm on Apr 16, 2011

Sorry, I got a comma in that sentence that shouldn't be there. I was referencing your article directly and suggesting that it was a good idea for a new approach, because your article said it was different than current approach. Btw, my sister is really into Buddhism.

Anna O'Neil said

at 1:46 pm on Apr 8, 2011

Please see my post above about how he ended up in Aurora. It is my understanding that Steven initially entered the Buddhist monastery more as a place of refuge rather than for solely religious reasons. It was a safe place to live, with good shelter,food and education. Stability and needs were met in a way that his home could not. It was my impression that many young boys entered the monastery for these reasons. However, the Buddhist part of him was and is there as well. I have offered to take Stephen to a Buddhist temple in Duluth. When he first arrived in the US he wasn't interested. But now I think he is missing it a bit. Maybe. Like many people's spirituality, Buddhism is not necessarily central to, or the focus of his life or identity. Buddhism is also a type of sprituality that is largely individual. There is no "God" per se, that it specifically promotes, and it doesn't require a church or temple to practice in. It suggest finding a Buddhist community for support, but this aspect is not necessary. Although, it has been a huge struggle to find anyone in Northern MN that can connect with these kids culturally or spiritually.

steven_usa2009@... said

at 7:54 pm on Apr 17, 2011

On behalf of Steven, regardless of his Buddhist roots "I don't want to live anywhere where there are too many people."

kevin.engel@... said

at 2:26 pm on Apr 8, 2011

I really like the 1st and 2nd elements of dialogue. "...Respect and tolerance...", and "people should attempt to have an open mind or, “beginner's mind.”" Those are great theories no matter what religion you believe in.

Genevieve.Bennett@st.bemidjistate.edu said

at 3:46 pm on Apr 8, 2011

I love the phrase "beginner's mind." It would be a great way to engage students. Especially upper level students, who often think they know everything already. I also love the idea of approaching something new or unfamiliar with a sense of wonder and curiosity. So often, I find myself approaching something new or unfamiliar with fear or skepticism. Wonder and curiosity would be so much more beneficial and positive.

Elizabeth Murray said

at 8:37 pm on Apr 10, 2011

Nice way to put it Genevieve -- approach with wonder and curiosity -- just like a toddler approaches everything! Why do most of us grow up and be hesitant and cautious?

Elizabeth Murray said

at 8:38 pm on Apr 10, 2011

These would be great words to post on our future classroom doors at the beginning of school......enter with respect.....enter with tolerance.....enter with a beginner's mind......

And as Genevieve state below -- perfect for any level of learner, but especially the "too cool for school" secondary kids!

Zach Johnson said

at 7:06 pm on Apr 11, 2011

To what degree do you think Buddhism is a "hippy" religion in the West? I know a lot of people with Asian ancestry practice it, but what about white people that do?

Anna O'Neil said

at 11:44 am on Apr 19, 2011

Being 18, and from a small village in Thailand, Steven said he doesn't know what a hippy is. When I described your question he laughed - hippies have long hair, monks shave their heads :-) Oddly, the next day in school, Steven learned about hippies. He doesn't recognize any connection with Buddhists

Joshua Voller said

at 6:23 pm on Apr 13, 2011

You mention that there are many various sub-groupings and schools of Buddhism. Do these groups see eye to eye or is there a feeling of this group is right and the others are wrong?

Anna O'Neil said

at 6:58 pm on Apr 17, 2011

I think the nature of Buddhism is pretty accepting of differences in general. I haven't gotten any perception of superiority from Buddhists on either side. Steven might elaborate more on this.

jon.weinhold@... said

at 6:50 pm on Apr 13, 2011

Is Buddhism really considered a hippy religion but Westerners? I would think that it is much more of a worldly religion considering many of the other beliefs consist of an all powerful deity or some other supernatural being that influences us. I guess worldy = hippy to some people.

Jaime Goulet said

at 7:37 am on Apr 16, 2011

Hi Steven,
Thank you for being part of our discussion. How do/did you confront bullying?

steven_usa2009@... said

at 8:10 pm on Apr 17, 2011

On behalf of Steven - Steven just told a story about confronting bullies in his monastery. He told me that there were cliques in his monastery. He described gangs Tangs and Geccos outside the temple who would pick fights with kids/monks inside the temple. Sometimes Steven felt like he needed to fight even though he didn't like to. He didn't want other kids to think he scared so he stood up to bullies and met their advances. He just said "I not go find a problem, but problem come find me." He thinks maybe kids picked fights because they didn't like the way someone looked or were jealous.

may.hsueh@... said

at 2:26 pm on Apr 16, 2011

I am aware of some claim they are Buddhists from other sub-groupings, believe in there are many gods. In Taiwan, there are many temples, and people went to a various of temples to pray to a various of gods, but they also follow the similar teachings as Anna mentioned.

steven_usa2009@... said

at 8:15 pm on Apr 17, 2011

Steven said, "There are many many temples in Thailand. Some temples were for different thing, some were to see beautiful, some visit to learn about history People also went to pray to get rid of bad dreams. These people were sprinkled with water by monks."

denise.larson@... said

at 5:28 pm on Apr 16, 2011

Steven- I was in Chiang Mai this February and learned more about Buddhism after visiting temples such as Doi ____? I can't imagine leaving an area that is so very concentrated and accepting of Buddhism to the States where there is such diversion. What would be two things that you would ask us future teachers to provide for you in school? What would be 2 things you want students to know or understand? How do you keep from getting frustrated with bullying? What saves you?

steven_usa2009@... said

at 8:52 pm on Apr 17, 2011

On behalf of Steven - Doi Suthep?...on the hill in Chiang Mai. Steven says "1. Use Thai language so I can learn" and "Play Sports all day and take out the English language. Or, Study hall day. Or close school with a quarter inch of snow" (Steven is giggling, just a joke). 2. Seriously, he would like his worksheets to be in Thai. Steven would like other students to know 1. "Thai Language." 2. He would like Thai holidays to be celebrated. He specifically referred to Songkran which was celebrated this April 13-15. He said this is a really fun water festival basically a three day water fight. he also said it is a time when young people go their family elders and monks in their village to apologize for things they have done wrong over the past year. In turn the elders sprinkle water on the wrong doers and young monks and wish for all their dreams to come true. This has changed into a massive nationwide 3 day water fight which Steven dearly misses. He especially like to throw water at the girls!

Loi Krathong is the other festival with fireworks and banana leaf lanterns floated on the river. this is a way to "say thank-you to Kong Ka (Ganges) river in India that people believe brings water to Thailand. Thank you for water to drink, shower, wash."

Richard S. Russell said

at 12:56 am on Apr 17, 2011

I note for the record that most flavors of Buddhism are technically atheistic — without god belief — but hardly anybody ever thinks that Buddhists lack a moral compass.

Marissa said

at 5:16 pm on Apr 17, 2011

Are your peers interested in your religion? What do you do or can you do to help them learn about it?

steven_usa2009@... said

at 8:53 pm on Apr 17, 2011

Some are interested, I think so. I talk to them about it sometimes

Dan Morrison said

at 6:49 am on Apr 19, 2011

The part about interconnectedness really caught my eye. It really reminded me of the movie "What the Bleep Do We Know." The movie uses scientific metaphor to show this interconnectedness. What is the Buddhist view on science?

Dan Morrison said

at 6:51 am on Apr 19, 2011

Let me redo that - as a religion, how does Buddhism deal with science? Can it be an integral part of Buddhism or is it held as kind of the "other" explanation of the world, just like Christianity is the explanation of why and science is what?

You don't have permission to comment on this page.